
Organization calls for greater transparency and scientific scrutiny as legal challenge continues
Safari Club International (SCI) is raising new concerns about the Catalina Island Conservancy's effort to eradicate the island's mule deer population. New information released by the Conservancy confirms reports that 670 deer were killed during the initial removal operation–more than three times the deer originally anticipated.
The operation, conducted in the Middle Ranch area during September and October, covered approximately 5,300 acres and was intended to assess removal methods, better understand deer numbers and distribution, and inform future islandwide operations.
The Conservancy's 2025 surveys estimated approximately 2,040 deer across the island's interior, excluding Avalon. The Conservancy also predicted that initial removal operations would remove 200 deer. However, the removal of 670 deer in a single operational area substantially exceeded initial projections, and casts doubt on the Conservancy's claims about the difficulty of controlling deer through hunting.
For SCI, these developments underscore the need for greater transparency, independent scrutiny, and a thorough evaluation of the decisions driving this project.
"When an operation results in the removal of more than three times the number of deer originally anticipated, it warrants a closer examination of the information guiding these decisions," said W. Laird Hamberlin, CEO of SCI. "We are talking about the permanent elimination of an established wildlife population, and decisions of this magnitude should never move forward without a transparent process, a thorough evaluation of the science, and meaningful public accountability."
SCI and its litigation partners have challenged the California Department of Fish and Wildlife's approval of the Catalina Island Restoration Project, arguing that the agency failed to comply with the environmental review and public participation requirements of California law. The coalition also challenged the agency's authority to authorize the complete eradication of a longstanding game mammal population through the Restoration Management Permit.
Although the Los Angeles County Superior Court dismissed the coalition's claims in September, the ruling did not resolve the broader concerns surrounding the ecological consequences of the project or the need for independent scrutiny of the Conservancy's underlying scientific claims. SCI appealed the lower court's decision and sought a stay of any further eradication until the appeal is resolved.
The latest developments make that commitment all the more important. The Conservancy has indicated that additional deer removal operations are planned to begin in mid-2027, with the initial assessment now serving as a basis for expanding its efforts.
"Once Catalina's deer population is eliminated, that resource cannot simply be restored," Hamberlin continued. "The consequences of this decision extend beyond the loss of individual animals. Catalina will lose an established wildlife population, a resource valued by residents and visitors, and a longstanding hunting opportunity for California sportsmen and women. We will not abandon the legal questions at the heart of this case simply because the first phase of removal has been completed."
SCI maintains that decisions involving the permanent removal of wildlife populations should be supported by rigorous scientific evaluation, lawful practices, and meaningful public participation.
About Safari Club International: Safari Club International is a global leader in protecting the freedom to hunt and advancing wildlife conservation worldwide. Through advocacy, litigation, and education, SCI fights to promote the sustainable use and management of wildlife resources while preserving the future of hunting and outdoor traditions. Visit www.safariclub.org today to join the mission.
